Showing posts with label victorian romance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label victorian romance. Show all posts

Monday, December 24, 2007

The Shadow and the Star, by Laura Kinsale [3]

***/***** (3/5)

Laura Kinsale sure doesn't believe in half measures. From what I've seen in three of her books so far, all of her characters are unique and her stories intense, every single one of them extreme cases of a trite plot in romance. I have to say that Kinsale breaths much needed life into trite romance plots. It's a wonder when a romance novel really tells a story beyond the sexually-experienced hero deflowering the innocent virgin. In THE SHADOW AND THE STAR, Laura Kinsale takes the tortured-soul-hero-with-demons routine to an emotional-angst extreme with her pretty-boy hero Samuel Gerard.. Kinsale's writing and prose enrich the reading experience tremendously and it's so nice to read her after so many poor romance novels. Kinsale skillfully sets the scene, builds the tension and concludes very satisfactorily. The oriental flavor and Hawaiian settings are nothing short of magnificent. I officially love all of Kinsale's endings from three of her books: SHADOWHEART (***), FLOWERS FROM THE STORM (****) and now, THE SHADOW AND THE STAR.

It's a tribute to Kinsale's characterizations and writing that even though all three of her heroines in the novels above are virgins, they still manage to stand out separately. Kinsale puts her heroes through a unique hell as well, and that too is delicious. I liked the way Kinsale flashed to Samuel's warrior training every other chapter for the first half of the novel and slowly but surely brought his perspective to the present. Our heroine Leda's subservience may rub some readers the wrong way, but if you can get past that, Leda's humor is something else. Leda's propriety and manners even during the most obscene circumstances proves absolutely hilarious. In Kinsale's note to her readers in this 449-page paperback, she reveals her inspiration for Leda's character: "[Leda] embodied the steadfast, kind and courageous ladies...the circle of grandmother and aunts and their friends in a small Texas town. Proper, generous, proud, sure of what was right and what was wrong..." And certainly, the circle of South Street ladies and their culture resonates in this book. I found Leda obstinately clinging to her propriety and morals in the most bizarre of circumstances and situations absolutely hilarious. Even after marriage, she continues to call her husband, "Dear Sir..." Leda is innocent, funny, proper, loyal to a fault and so caring and compassionate, any guy would give the world to her. And she would deserve it. Leda's humor is the highlight of the novel, and the book consequently belongs to Leda Etoile. That the novel belongs to Leda is even more astonishing given the inspiration for THE SHADOW AND THE STAR derives from Samuel's brief appearance in THE HIDDEN HEART which points the spotlight on Lady Tess and Gryphon Meridon.

"Really, I should like to have my own garden, with a fish pond in it, full of goldfish with tails like silk. Do you ever think of things such as that, Mr. Gerard? Whatever do gentlemen think about, I wonder?" She pondered the question, and answered herself. "Political difficulties, I suppose. It must be very trying and dull to be a man."

My problems with this novel stem from a pacing standpoint and the heavy reliance on the Ashland characters (characters from the prior book THE HIDDEN HEART). If you thought FLOWERS FROM THE STORM slow-developing, you'll find THE SHADOW AND THE STAR much more so. In fact, I thought this book never found its drive until the finale. This book also contains elements of the supernatural which fog the action sequences.

The Story, possible SPOILERS.

Our tortured hero Samuel Gerard is described as a handsomely perfect Gabriel and he harbors a lot of emotional angst over an abusive childhood. After Lady Tess takes in the young boy Samuel as part of her family, he grows up in a caring environment at Hawaii and under the tutelage of his martial arts master Dojun (originally the Ashlands' butler). Years later, at 27-28, the Ashlands and Samuel return to England. In a dressmaker's shop, Samuel's beauty awes Leda Etoile. In London, martial arts expert Samuel plants filched valuable items in shoddy establishments to uncover their underhanded practices. Practically invisible to Leda, Samuel utilizes Leda's cramped upper floor apartment as a haven during his heists. An injury to his leg prohibits Samuel from returning a stolen sword mount (the hilt).

Strained finances and unwanted advances compel Leda to accept Samuel's proposition of a position as his secretary. Things progress from there and despite the fact that Samuel has always envisioned marrying Lady Tess' daughter Kai (Lady Katherine), a publicized night of passion joins Samuel and Leda in marriage instead. Samuel and Leda's union represents a first in the romance genre for me: both are virgins. Kinsale handles it very delicately, very sweetly as both of their innocence wrenches your heart.

Events shift to Hawaii towards the second half of the novel as Leda outfits the beautiful home Samuel has built there. The stolen sword mount and Dojun's purpose takes center stage and the action finally starts to pick up. Japanese legends, martial arts and the Hawaiian backdrop lend this a refreshing romantic reading experience. Not to mention the very unique characters: Leda's hilarious propriety and Samuel's anguished emotional angst.

Another excellent offering from an adept author.

Friday, November 2, 2007

When We Touch, by Shannon Drake [1]

*/***** (1/5)

When he touched her, it was as if he did so because he had to, as if he had no other choice in the world, as if she were the greatest, most alluring treasure in existence...

Vaguely following Jack the Ripper's butchery of prostitutes during the Victorian era, Shannon Drake continues to excel at making belligerent hero-and-heroine interactions fun in WHEN WE TOUCH. Unfortunately, similar to an earlier novel I read by Shannon Drake COME THE MORNING (***), this 444-page paperback tends to meander in tiresome discourses quite a bit. I found this novel worse because the meandering discourses we find here aren't as historically informative as in COME THE MORNING. Although I liked both lead characters here, they didn't stand out as much as COME THE MORNING's hero and heroine either. The prose, plotting and pacing all seemed amateur and the entire reading experience seems to drag and stretch mercilessly as a result. Many of the people in WHEN WE TOUCH are factual such as Inspector Abberline, the Queen, and the royal family. I was reminded of the 2001 movie FROM HELL starring Johnny Depp (played Abberline) which was darker and a lot more interesting. Similar to FROM HELL, we encounter the theory here about an illicit royal marriage between the Prince and a Catholic prostitute producing a possible heir. WHEN WE TOUCH suggests many theories for the violent murders of prostitutes including the one purported by the movie FROM HELL about a maniacal doctor going on a rampage to preserve the royal bloodlines and eliminate all prostitutes.

WHEN WE TOUCH balances two basic plots: the romance between Lady Maggie Graham and Lord Jamie Langdon, and Maggie's noble perseverance to aid East End people living in poverty, especially prostitutes. Maggie also endeavors to uncover schemers during the Victorian era such as spiritualists communing for a seance which supposedly reunites grieving people with their deceased loved ones. Maggie's humanitarian activities in the decrepit part of London (East End) eventually lead to the Jack-the-Ripper plot. The sparse moments of romance and dull love scenes between Maggie and Jamie take a firm backseat to Maggie's escapades in East End and a spiritualist out to get her. I appreciated the book's attempt at a thrilling, nail-biting plot intermingled by an entertaining, yet combative romantic interaction, but I found the whole read still fairly dry.

The Premise.

Maggie's brother the Baron Justin Graham finds himself deep in debt. Widowed years ago, Maggie helps her brother avoid debtor's prison by agreeing to marry the doddering Viscount Charles Langdon old enough to be Maggie's grandfather. Charles' protective nephew Jamie Langdon catches Maggie's eyes and each enjoy an early tumultuous relationship. Jamie mistrusts Maggie and Maggie detests Jamie for believing the worst of her. When Charles' embittered daughter Arianna arrives for the wedding, sparks fly between Arianna and Maggie's brother Justin.

Meanwhile, Maggie's continued efforts in East End to uncover fraudulent schemers and help the impoverished place her in more and more danger. Jamie keeps an eye on her to make sure she doesn't cheat on his elderly uncle and instead ends up rescuing her from a seance plotted by dangerous people. Adrian Alexander is one of these dangerous people. Alexander escapes capture and vows to exact vengeance on the woman who uncovers his scheme: Maggie. When Arianna entangles herself with Alexander to oust her stepmother Maggie, Maggie must save her bitter stepdaughter Arianna.

The first half of the book mostly chronicles Maggie and Jamie's truculent relationship climaxing at Maggie's wedding with Jamie's uncle the Viscount Charles Langdon. In the background, we hear about brutal murders of prostitutes in the first half of the book. The storyline with the murders and Jack the Ripper monopolizes the second half of the book however and endlessly stretches this tiresome book. The pacing seemed to stagnate quite a bit during the second half as the focus shifted away from the romance. I'd enjoy the oblique plot with Maggie's seances and the brutal murders if it was handled in a darkly interesting way.

Again, not a bad novel and it seemed to offer more than the stereotypical romance storyline but still suffered from an uninteresting plot dealing with Jack the Ripper. I'd imagine Drake's strengths mostly rest with the medieval era.

Saturday, July 28, 2007

Beyond Innocence, by Emma Holly [2]

**/***** (2/5)

Not a bad novel, but also fairly dull overall. I like Emma Holly's writing, and it demonstrates a skillful knack for imagery. Her settings are also good, and much better than most romance novelists. The characters aren't bad either, Holly's hero Edward is moderately believable, and her heroine isn't childish and even funny at times. I found the supporting cast of characters surprisingly fun. Neither hero nor heroine really stood apart from romance archetypes however, because once again, you have the sexually-experienced, chiseled hero igniting an innocent virgin's passion, where every touch melts and every dark look inflames. I found Holly's references to Edward's size egregious. Then again, maybe I shouldn't be surprised by a virgin's curiosity over such intimacies in the male anatomy. Although known for sensuality, I thought Holly's "love" scenes were flat. In fact, in terms of unadulterated carnal sensuality, the one Sylvia Day book I read sizzles much, much more.

Similar to Tarr's VANQUISHED, Holly's BEYOND INNOCENCE takes place in Victorian England. The similarity ends there however. Whereas VANQUISHED predicates a dark intensity closely tied to the historical suffrage movement, BEYOND INNOCENCE settles on a more lighter tone solely portraying an innocent virgin's journey to discover passion. It took me a while to finish the 295-page BEYOND INNOCENCE, primarily because of my apathy and disinterest.

The Story, possible SPOILERS.

The Earl of Greystowe Edward Burbrooke wishes to protect his younger brother Freddie from scandal. Evidently, someone walked in on Freddie and a footman. The taciturn, cold Edward nourished little Freddie since they were little boys and after their father and mother passes away, Edward happily assumes a parent's responsibilities towards Freddie. Convinced Freddie will find love with the right, pretty woman, Edwards hunts for this woman. Edward's solicitor Mr. Bowry brings to Edward's attention Miss Florence Fairleigh, a pretty, poor country girl wishing to marry a nice gentleman. Realizing she lacks an aristocratic background and estates, Florence is practical and only wishes a gentleman who's kind to her, a possible younger son or a tradesman. She has no requirements for love.

Edward immediately lusts for Florence after laying his sights on her for the first time. Hoping Florence will incite his brother's desires, Edward arranges Florence to have a formal season and coming-out. Edward orders his brother to woo Florence into marriage thereby saving his brother's reputation.

The book then fractures and splinters as the forbidden nature of Edward & Florence's liaison seem to fuel their attractions. When another rumor of Freddie departing a gay club surfaces, Edward takes everyone back to his country seat at Greystowe. At Greystowe, Freddie injures his leg and Edward and Florence share more time together.

I don't quite understand the reasoning which finally prompts Edward to marry Florence. Florence makes a comment about marrying Edward's brother Freddie while having Edward's children, and Edward thinks she must truly love to remotely consider something like that. And then he comes to grips with his own love for Florence and decides to marry her. That was weird and icky. So basically, Edward finally deciding to marry Florence depended on Florence considering having Edward's babies while married to Edward's brother Freddie?

While Edward lusts for Florence and admits to himself that he loves her, he persists his quest to "save" his brother by marrying Florence and Freddie. The entire notion was dumb. This kind of forbidden "love" didn't make it romantic, and it certainly wasn't anymore sensual. Then, when Freddie leaves with the steward, it's like Edward forgets his obstinate resolve to marry Freddie and Florence. Edward pursues Florence instead.

I thought BEYOND INNOCENCE was banal, though Emma Holly's writing was good and the characters did not annoy me.

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Vanquished, by Hope Tarr [2]

**/***** (2/5)

In the historical backdrop of Victorian London, VANQUISHED (2006) follows the women's suffrage movement in the late 19th century. I had high hopes and it began with some intriguing promise, but it quickly took a nosedive for the worse. VANQUISHED includes some graphic sexual brutality and some very audacious carnal scenes. None of this is the problem though. The writing and content was aggressive and brutal, and I didn't mind that either. My problem: for the majority of the book, VANQUISHED highlights a woman's insecurities with her appearance and it's overwhelmingly written for a female's sensibilities and a female's vision of the perfect hero. After the intriguing opening featuring Hadrian St. Claire's devil's bargain to ruin the heroine Callie, the book then focuses on Callie's insecurities at every turn. It got tiring. Old. And exhausting.

I found the Victorian backdrop solid, and the writing very strong. The historical details seemed to deftly supplement the story. I liked that Hadrian wasn't a duke, earl, viscount or baron. He hails from a poverty-stricken childhood, a prostitute's son, and tries pay off debts as a humble photographer. Regrettably, there's too many things to dislike about Hadrian's character too. Some romance novelists manage to realize believable heroes in love. These heroes' loves for their heroines is heartfelt, yet subtle. A bit gruff, yet empowering and very giving. By contrast, in the frequent times Hadrian thinks about his heroine Callie, his love for Callie can only be described by a very suffocating nature. I applaud Callie's sensuality, but c'mon, you have an insecure near-virgin armoring herself with make-believe spectacles, ugly hats and bundles of clothing transition to wanting anal sex? I didn't quite see it. I suppose all of Callie's insecurities and lewd desires somehow predicated her public expose in the book's finale, I'm not exactly sure. Some sort of disturbing redemption and fortification of her confidence. Even made it seem like Callie's character journey required the public expose.

The ending falls back on some sort of psychological redemption actually warranting Callie's public expose as a device to fortify her self-respect and confidence. So having her assets on full display to the world actually helps her emotionally? I know she ignores the ribald jeers during her speech at the very end, but c'mon that kind of thing doesn't go away. After she marries Hadrian, both would bear the brunt of a lot of obscene remarks. Especially considering how public Callie's life as a suffragist leader has been.

The ending seemed to imply Hadrian St. Claire's compromising pictures ultimately caused the defeat of the bill which would grant women the vote (because despite Dandridge blackmailing Hadrian, Hadrian is in the center of it). After meetings with Lord Stonevale and the PM and Foreign Secretary Lord Salisbury, it seemed Callie was on the verge of pushing the women's vote bill through Parliament. Yet true to the book's purpose, Hadrian vanquishes the bill and her efforts. It's Hadrian who develops the compromising photograph in the first place, it's Hadrian who leaves the developed photograph unattended for the villain to steal, it's Hadrian who fails to retrieve it, it's Hadrian who gets stupidly beat up.

Not only is Hadrian useless, but the thing with the photograph proves he's dumb. After taking the compromising photograph of Callie, he goes insofar as to develop the photograph and leave his shop unattended when he knows Dandridge hired someone to tail him! When he knows that Dandridge desperately desires a photograph ruining Callie! Hadrian-- nice show, sport, just brilliant.

So he takes the compromising photograph (when he fully understands the danger if it falls into the wrong hands), develops it before he leaves so the baddies can steal it, then goes after Dandridge to steal it back only to find himself beaten and bruised. Then all he can think of is throwing himself at Callie's feet and asking for forgiveness (which he had already after his confession). My gawd, that's a drowning love. Totally, completely, choking the life out of him. He pines endlessly. I really didn't want to hear it anymore.

VANQUISHED belabors on characters' appearances a bit too much for my tastes. With Hadrian and Callie, it's more about shallow appearances, and Callie's insecurities obfuscates any potential for chemistry or passion or love. You have a near-virgin, very insecure over her tall, unseemly appearance and very sensitive about how she walks, dances, etc. She commonly drapes herself behind bundles of ugly clothing. And of course you have your obligatory tall, dark and handsome hero. Then again, it's written with a female's sensitivities in mind so I can hardly judge too harshly here.

The insecurities and descriptions of appearances aren't nearly as repetitive as other novels but the book never manages to rise above them either. Never manages to rise above the common appearance hangover romance novels have with a heroine's insecurities and hero's Adonis good looks. It gets to be a bit too much at the charity ball and then later, in Hadrian's flat. Callie relentlessly drones on and on about her insecurities, too big in the bosom and bottom, too tall, can't dance, etc., etc., etc. Despite Hadrian (constantly) assuring her and lavishing her with compliments about her lovely face, soft skin, curvy figure, etc., Callie persists on latching on to her insecurities. Hope Tarr even uses Callie's insecurity to manipulate Hadrian into taking the compromising photograph, something he's reluctant to do at first. When Hadrian comments on her breast after their first time, she again retreats into her shell of insecurities. Enough already, you have the tall, dark, and handsome perfect-guy with a huge, turgid phallus lusting after you and pleasuring you!

I thought Hadrian doesn't do enough for a male character, and doesn't act. I don't mind him being a prostitute's son and hailing from the low, poor classes (in fact, I applaud Hope Tarr for that), but he doesn't do anything. He fails to act when he suspects that Josiah Dandridge has something more personal against Callie. He doesn't do anything when he suspects he's being trailed. Instead he mopes around feeling something strong for Callie and anguishes over the devil's bargain he's struck to ruin Callie and again feels sorry for himself. Anyone who obviously cares for the Callie like he does would at least try to figure out the connection between Callie and Dandridge actively. They would try to discover who's trailing him and subvert him. They would do something, anything, instead of moping around for Callie and waiting for her to come around so you can take her photographs. Hadrian has a barrister friend and if he's too prideful to ask for a loan from the barrister, he could at least enlist his barrister friend's aid in other capacities. Maybe Hadrian could get his friend Rourke to help with the person trailing him. Something anything, stop moping around and pining! We get it, you feel something strong for Callie unlike any of the other women you've bedded. Now get on with it!

The lovesick notions in this novel are too drowning instead of empowering or heartfelt (at least from a male point-of-view). The ending inundates its readers with endless words of love which didn't seem to ring true as a result. I sure wasn't convinced.

On the plus side--

"On the one hand you say women should choose for themselves who and how they should love and yet when that freedom leads them astray, you assume they must have been seduced against their wills." -Hadrian St. Claire from Hope Tarr's VANQUISHED

I enjoyed some of the stimulating conversation between Callie & Hadrian on the suffrage movement. They were actually witty and fun. Although Callie's cause is very worthy and noble, I liked how Hope Tarr allowed the hero to single out some failings in Callie's opinions and ideals. Thankfully the verbal sparring wasn't a one-way street as Hadrian questions Callie's ideals for women amongst the lower classes (they seem to only apply to "well-bred women") and her contradicting views on marriage (women should be free to choose the who and how on love, yet if they chose badly, it's society's fault since they were raised that way and didn't know any better). Shoulder some responsibility for your choices!